After Trio of Explosions, Scientists Say Supernova Is Imminent
09.30.04
Three powerful blasts from three wholly different regions in space have
left scientists scrambling. The blasts, which lasted only a few seconds,
might be early alert systems for star explosions called supernovae,
which could start appearing any day now.
Image above: Artist's concept of Supernova. Click on image to view animation (1.9 MB). Credit: NASA
The first two blasts, called X-ray flashes, occurred on September 12 and
16. These were followed by a more powerful burst on September 24 that
seems to be on the cusp between an X-ray flash and a full-fledged
gamma-ray burst, a discovery interesting in its own right. If these
signals lead to supernovae, as expected, scientists would have a tool to
predict star explosions and then watch them go off from start to
finish.
A team led by Dr. George Ricker of the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology detected the explosions with NASA's High-Energy Transient
Explorer (HETE-2). Science teams around the world using space- and
ground-based observatories have joined in, torn and conflicted over
which burst region to track most closely.
"Each burst has been beautiful," said Ricker. "Depending on how these
evolve, they could support important theories about supernovae and
gamma-ray bursts. These past two weeks have been like 'cock, fire,
reload.' Nature keeps on delivering, and our HETE-2 satellite keeps on
responding flawlessly."
Gamma-ray bursts are the most powerful explosions known other than the
Big Bang. Many appear to be caused by the death of a massive star
collapsing into a black hole. Others might be from merging black holes
or neutron stars. In either case, the event likely produces twin, narrow
jets in opposite directions, which carry off tremendous amounts of
energy. If one of jets points to Earth, we see this energy as a
"gamma-ray" burst.
Image
above: Scientists believe gamma ray bursts can be triggered by a
star's collapse. Click on image to view animation. (4.19 MB) Credit:
NASA
The lower-energy X-ray flashes might be gamma-ray bursts viewed slightly
off angle from the jet direction, somewhat similar to how a flashlight
is less blinding when viewed at an angle. The majority of light
particles from X-ray flashes, called photons, are X rays -- energetic,
but not quite as powerful as gamma rays. Both types of bursts last only a
few milliseconds to about a minute. HETE-2 detects the bursts, studies
their properties, and provides a location so that other observatories
can study the burst afterglow in detail.
The trio of bursts from the past few weeks has the potential of settling
two long-standing debates. Some scientists say that X-ray flashes are
different beasts all together, not related to gamma-ray bursts and
massive star explosions. Detecting a supernova in the region where the
X-ray flash appeared would refute that belief, instead confirming the
connection between the two. Follow-up observations of the September 24
burst, named GRB040924 for the date it was observed, are already
solidifying the theory of a cosmic explosion continuum from X-ray
flashes up through gamma-ray bursts.
More interesting for supernova hunters is the fact that X-ray flashes
are closer to Earth than gamma-ray bursts are. While the connection
between gamma-ray bursts and supernovae has been made, these supernovae
are too distant to study in detail. X-ray flashes might be signals for
supernovae that scientists can actually sink their teeth into and
observe in detail. Yet for now, it is just watch and wait.
"Last year the discovery of GRB030329 by HETE-2 sealed the connection
between gamma-ray bursts and massive supernovae," said Prof. Stanford
Woosley of the University of California at Santa Cruz, who has
championed several theories concerning the physics of star explosions.
"These two September bursts may be the first time we see an X-ray flash
lead to a supernova. We might know very soon."
In addition to all of this, GRB040924 goes on record as generating the
fastest response ever for a gamma-ray burst satellite. HETE-2 detected
the burst and relayed information through the NASA-operated Gamma-ray
Burst Coordinates Network in under 14 seconds, which led to an optical
detection about 15 minutes later with the Palomar 60-inch telescope,
just north of San Diego. Dr. Derek Fox of Caltech was the lead on this
observation.
Image above: HETE-2 and the Gamma-ray Burst Coordinates Network. Click on image to view animation (3.79 MB). Credit: NASA
"We all expect much more of this type of exciting science to come after
the launch of Swift," said Dr. Anne Kinney, director of NASA's Universe
Division. Swift, to launch in October, contains three telescopes (gamma
ray, X ray and UV/optical) for quick burst detection, swift relay of
information, and immediate follow-up observations of the afterglow.
HETE was built by MIT as a mission of opportunity under the NASA
Explorer Program, collaboration among U.S. universities, Los Alamos
National Laboratory, and scientists and organizations in Brazil, France,
India, Italy and Japan.
Additional information about the physics of star explosions:
While many scientists say that X-ray flashes are gamma-ray bursts viewed
slightly off angle, another theory is that the star explosion that
causes the X-ray flash is rich in baryons (a family of particles that
includes protons and neutrons), as opposed to leptons (particles that
include electrons). A baryon-dominated blast would produce more X rays,
and a lepton-dominated blast would produce more gamma rays. This is
because the baryons move more slowly than leptons; and slower moving
matter would make a softer (lower-energy) burst at all angles.

Image above: This computer simulation shows the distribution particles
in the jet as it breaks out of the star. Yellow and orange are very
high energy and will ultimately make a gamma-ray burst. Note also the
presence of some small amount of energy in mildly relativistic matter
(blue) at larger angles off the jet. These will produce x-ray flashes
that may be much more frequently seen. Click on image to view animation
(5.96 MB). Credit: Weiqun Zhang and Stan Woosley
According to Dr. Stanford Woosley, the supernova / gamma-ray burst
connection is this: When a massive star runs out of nuclear fuel, its
core will collapse, yet without the star's outer part knowing. A black
hole forms inside surrounded by a disk of accreting matter, and, within a
few seconds, this launches a jet of matter away from the black hole
that ultimately makes the gamma-ray burst. The jet pierces the outer
shell of the star about nine seconds after its creation. The jet of
matter, in conjunction with vigorous winds of newly forged radioactive
nickel-56 blowing off the disk inside, shatters the star within seconds.
This shattering represents the supernova event, and the amount of
radioactive nickel-56 gives its brightness. However, from our vantage
point, we will not see the supernova until about two weeks after the
gamma-ray burst because the region is enshrouded by gas and dust,
blocking light.